Cottage Bakery & Cafe

230 E Benton St, Iowa City, IA 52240, USA

Address:	230 E Benton St, Iowa City, IA 52240, USA
Phone:	+1 319-351-0052
Site:	cottagebakerycafe.com
Rating:	3.2
Working:	6:30AM–5:30PM 6:30AM–5:30PM 6:30AM–5:30PM 6:30AM–5:30PM 6:30AM–5:30PM 6:30AM–2PM Closed

Location

Photos 6

Reviews 18

Amanda Brecht

A few years ago we had quite a few cupcakes and two cakes done for a graduation. The cupcakes were great and the one cake was also great. The second cake, which we ordered pretty last minute, tasted good but looked terrible. It looked as though they spent about five minutes decorating it, and it was quite embarrassing. It really kind of changed my opinion of the place because I felt like a small business bakery should have a little more pride in their work, considering HyVee could make the same cake at a cheaper price yet I am choosing to give them business. Nevertheless, the Oreo cupcakes were a complete hit. Since itd been a few years and my dad hadnt stopped talking about the cupcakes, we had a cake made for his birthday. It was nothing I couldnt have made in terms of decorating, and I was hoping it would taste just as great. It was just okay. Nothing great like we remembered, which was disappointing. It was a little dry as well. Was sad to have it again and not have it taste nearly as good. Will probably go elsewhere next time.

Anonymous User

The Cottage was recently sold to a new owner and moved to a new location. While some elements of the old Cottage remain, it is better to think of this bakery/cafe as a new establishment so as to not be disappointed. While the food is still very good, the location leaves a lot to be desired and the service is TERRIBLE. We felt we were interrupting the gossiping employees just to place our order---three of them literally stood there and stared at us while we waited for service. The advertised "grab n go" food is just that because you arent encouraged to sit or even stand around. They really want you to leave. If you are in the neighborhood and looking for great food, go someplace else and dont waste your time with people who dont want your business.

Anonymous User

We had the Cottage cater our wedding reception, rehearsal dinner, AND they did our cake. Everything was awesome and delicious! I lost count of the compliments we got on the food and cake. They incorporate local food and put unique twists on classic foods, so that both grandma and foodies are happy. We had the Cottage do it all and not for lack research. They were the fourth caterer we personally interviewed. We just loved the the people. They were willing to work with our budget, they were relaxed, professional, and fun -- an awesome combo! Thank you Cottage for making our wedding deliciously wonderful!

Anonymous User

$28 for a chocolate birthday cake. Poorly frosted....wouldnt fix for me. Layers were uneven. Cake had a tilt. Didnt mind too much, sometimes the ugliest cakes are the best. NOT THIS ONE! It was dry and tasteless. I had to appologize to everyone at the party. When I told them about it there was no sorry. They said their cakes never sit out for more than a day and theyve never had a problem before. I give this place 6 months before they are out of business. This is not the same Cottage I grew up with.

Melissa Truong Warth

For a small business, you would think they would be flexible as a caterer. Instead, they have rigid minimums and do not allow for variety when ordering. We recently had The Cottage cater a baby shower, and they require 2 dozen of the same item. When hosting a party for 12-15 individuals, you are not allowed much variety in ordering trays. The woman on the phone was quite snappy and unapologetic for their policies. Next time, well be looking for a more flexible and courteous vendor.

Shannon Wood

I recently had a cake done for a bridal shower and it was a 1/4 sheet cake for $31. They didnt get my order right and decorated it wrong and with the wrong colors and no flowers like I asked. When I asked for them to make it right, they refused saying the decorating is complimentary therefore there is no way to reimburse for it. They said they would give my a 5% discount on the next cake...there wont be a next cake. Poor customer service.

Anonymous User

I will not be going back solely because of the slap-in-the-face attitude of the clerk. I sat in line for 10 minutes with another person waiting to order. The clerk, with her counter-culture look of nose rings & apathetic glassy eyes, just bypassed everyone waiting and went to the guy that just walked in. Even his expression was like wtf, what about these people. Would have loved to go, but will be dis-recommending to friends in Iowa City.

Jon Anderson

On a recent visit had a stronger than typical (a good thing) iced coffee with two baked items: chocolate croissant and a berry muffin. Croissant was light, very flavorful. Muffin was just ok. Sat outsided at the small tables.

Peter Chanthanakone

2 day old cupcakes for $2. Its like Mollys cupcakes selling a day old cupcakes for a 33% discount. Go to somewhere for fresh bakes. Too bad....

Elizabeth Hubing

If youre looking for a quaint bakery with a friendly face, the Cottage is the place to go. The expresso chocolate chip muffin is hard to beat!

Jonathan Petrou

The food was delicious! I got a chicken panini sandwich and a couple of soups. I enjoyed it all and would most definitely return!

이지윤

Cheap cupcakes but it feels like yesterdays. Frosting is dry and hard, and cake too.

Aaron Van Noy

Ive gotten some small items here and food was kinda hit or miss. Mostly good food!

Hiroko Czuprynski

Their cakes are amazing, and the staff are so nice!