College Shell Auto Care

1400 W Hillsdale Blvd, San Mateo, CA 94403, USA

Address:	1400 W Hillsdale Blvd, San Mateo, CA 94403, USA
Phone:	+1 650-727-6420
Site:	collegeshellautocare.com
Rating:	3.9
Working:	8AM–5PM 8AM–5PM 8AM–5PM 8AM–5PM 8AM–5PM Closed Closed

Location

Photos 7

Reviews 16

Linda Jackson

College Plaza Shell has been my main car maintenance source since the mid-90s. Ive consistently received excellent service from them and all employees have been friendly, knowledgeable and helpful. I ended up owning a 1997 Audi A4 for 14 years, and it was thanks to College Plaza Shell that my car stayed in such good shape throughout that time - Ive since sold it to a friend who continues to drive and enjoy it. A variety of issues with the car surfaced over time and College Plaza Shell was almost always able to diagnose and address the issue. When they couldnt fix an issue themselves they were always honest and up front about it and would do their best to recommend how to go about taking care of it. Similarly, I have never felt like I was being pushed into more repairs or service than what was necessary at the time; they treat their customers as long-term partners and recommend the service they honestly believe is needed, even if that means less revenue (sometimes even zero revenue) for them. I highly recommend this business to anyone needing friendly local automotive care.

Ed Rhein

I have been having my full stable of cars (up to 6 cars at one time when my now-adult children were living at home) serviced by College Plaza Shell for over 20 years & have always been appreciative of the honesty & the competency shown in keeping all of these different cars in running condition. Ive always felt confident that the two Daves that preceded Alfredo & now Alfredo will give me honest opinions as to what needs to be done to keep the cars in working condition without discovering "unknown" problem areas that would increase the costs. Now that Alfredo & his trusty sidekick , Sal , are running the operation ; I continue to have full confidence in their ability to keep my cars (now down to 2) in tip-top shape & I will continue to bring them to College Plaza Shell until I either move away or get to an age where I can no longer drive. Ed Rhein

Nobu Tanaka

It is very hard for me to accept that there are a number of customers reviewing College Plaza Shell being just one STAR... I have been a customer over the last 10 years and I have been always appreciating and felt very enthusiastic with the job Alfredo provided to me in various occasions with my cars. He is always honest and open for suggestions, and tell me what he found and not found (yet). He is always a very good listener that he pays a very careful attention to what I tell him. I cannot explain what my problem is technically, obviously; however, he will get it eventually, and try to figure out what I meant to say. I always appreciate his service.

Phil Haynes

Alfredo is awesome. I recently moved to N. CA and work around the corner. I needed my oil changed (after a 3000 mile cross country drive) and wanted my brakes checked out. I called in the morning when he opened, I had my truck down the hill in 5 minutes and Alfredo took care of me before noon! It was such great service and I really enjoyed working with him. I plan to have my truck serviced there each time it needs it and Im in town. He also filled all my fluids and even reset my tire air regulator which I didnt ask him to do but was needed. Great service, easy in and out and IN THE BAY AREA? Thats 5 stars.

donna kuwahara

Love these guys- have been going 2 them 4 a decade or so & theyve fixed major as well as bizarre stuff 4 me & have done so in a timely fashion. & have never gouged me on price! I originally went. 2 this shop becz my car was dying & barely made it up hwy. 92 & they were the closest shop. Fully expected to B overcharged but they did not! Ive been going 2 them ever since & have found them. 2 B honest, trustworthy, & efficient & I truly like Alfredo & Sal! They bailed me out of automotive jams many times over the years & They R my "Go To" guys whenever I have a vehicle problem!

Anonymous User

I went there to get my water pump replaced (about a 300 dollar job) since it was leaking, and they recommended that I replace my complete cooling system (on an american car) with a Toyota cooling system (3000 dollar job). When I absolutely refused (even though he told me that I was making a big and foolish mistake), he did what I wanted them to. The only upside to this experience was that they did a good job replacing the pump.

Rob Huffman

Alfredo at College Shell Auto Care is fast, honest and fair just like Dave who turned over the business to him. Sal, the other mechanic, is great, too. Ive been trusting my familys fleet--including a hybrid--to Alfredo for years. I trust his advice and his work. Make an appointment to have your oil changed, tires rotated and brakes checked and spend the hour waiting by having a bagel at Sonoma Valley Bagel down the street.

Paula Edmondson

Alfredo and Sal are always ready to diagnose, repair and especially explain any problems with the vehicles we have been bringing in for service. I have felt that their attention to detail and honest repair advice has been exceptional and very much appreciated. Service with a smile and integrity are what they bring to their work. We highly recommend them for all of our auto care.

Ed Rhein

Alfredo & Sal (& their predecessors at College Plaza Shell) have been keeping my long list of various makes & models of cars running smoothly for well over 20 years. I would recommend them most heartily as a great place to take you car to be serviced due to their diligence & attention to detail. Youre in Good Hands with Alfredo & Sal!!

Jill Daly

Since these men have taken over the business the quality of care at this facility is outstanding. They go the extra mile and provide excellent advice as well as service, helping me to make long term plans for the cars maintenance. On time, honest, and friendly.

Karen Chew

I have always found College Plaza Shell to be honest and reliable. They have been generous with services and time, sometimes checking batteries and tires for free. They are also very convenient, as I can leave and pick up the cars late at night.

Carolee Fucigna

College Plaza Shell has been our place for car care for almost 15 years. I have always found them to be personable, honest, efficient, and flexible with their schedule. Alfredo and Sal do excellent work and have earned our trust.

Lucy Mulkerrins

College Shell has been taking care of our cars for 23 years. Alfredo and Sal provide a great service in a personal manner.We have appreciated their excellent work and will continue to give them our business.

Anonymous User

Gas prices are a joke. These people are real thieves... I drive an extra 2 miles to the Chevron off De Anza and save like 10 bucks on filling up my car. Except in an emergency, do NOT fill up here.

Anonymous User

estimated one hour ($100+) to change the top motor mount on a Saturn, This is a 5 bolt 10 min problem including the time to put the floor-jack under the engine. conclusion: NOT TO BE TRUSTED

John Benson

I have been taking my cars to these guys for at least 11 years now. They know what needs to be done per manufacturer recommendations and wont try to sell you work that isnt necessary.